|
Selling mangles markets amid air of
uncertainty
By Adam Shell, USA TODAY
NEW YORK — Wall Street has
endured a horrific week of trading, in which the Dow Jones
industrial average has lost more than 1200 points, part of
the worst 7-day streak ever.
After 4 consecutive days of new
bear market lows, many investors are hoping a bottom is
near.
When the stock market shut down for
4 days after terrorists toppled the World Trade Center,
many Wall Street pros viewed the layoff as a positive, a
much-needed period of reflection that would diminish the
desire to dump stocks in a panic.
But after thinking things over,
investors wracked with uncertainty fled stocks anyway.
Stock prices have been slammed ever
since trading resumed Monday after the longest shutdown
since the Depression. The Dow Jones industrial average,
the bluest of the blue chips, has plunged more than 1200
points, or 12.8%, in 4 days. More than $1.2 trillion
dollars in shareholder wealth, as measured by the Wilshire
5000 index, has been wiped out.
Once-complacent investors are
running scared. Confidence in stocks has been undermined
— at least for the time being. Wall Street is filled
with uncertainty — the equivalent of kryptonite for
stock prices. The USA is on the verge of a war with an
unknown enemy. The economy, in the words of Federal
Reserve Chairman Alan Greenspan, has ground to a halt.
Corporate earnings are dropping fast, and layoffs are
mounting due to massive disruptions to U.S. businesses, a
result of the terrorist strikes.
"Financial markets are built
on trust and confidence, and if that is damaged, it's not
hard to understand why stock prices are moving down
sharply," says Jeremy Siegel, finance professor at
the University of Pennsylvania's Wharton School.
So who's selling? Pretty much
everyone who still owns stocks.
Big institutions top the list.
Thursday, when the Dow plunged 383 points to 8376,
professional investors were regularly putting in sell
orders of 100,000 shares for blue chips such as General
Electric and Microsoft. Block trades ranging from 10,000
shares to 30,000 shares were the rule, not the exception.
"It's the big institutions saying, 'Oh, my God,'
" says Chris Wolfe, strategist at J.P. Morgan.
Individual investors have caught
the selling bug, too. There are signs that mutual fund
investors are taking losses and shifting into bonds and
money market funds. Mutual fund giants T. Rowe Price and
Vanguard Group both reported stepped-up redemption
activity this week — but reported no panic.
Vanguard spokesman Brian Mattes
said Thursday that some customers were making small
adjustments, such as moving 20% of their holdings from
stock funds into money market funds. "They're
rebalancing at the margins," he says.
But those small adjustments add up.
TrimTabs.com, a research firm that tracks fund flows,
estimates that investors yanked $9.4 billion out of stock
funds Sept. 17-19 — the same amount they withdrew for
the entire month of August. Still, it paled in comparison
with the record $15.9 billion that fled stock funds in the
3 days ended March 19, 2001.
Traders say intense selling
pressure also is coming from hedge funds, foreign
investors and large insurance companies that need to raise
money quickly to help fund huge payouts to victims of the
terrorist attacks on the Pentagon, World Trade Center and
a downed jet in rural Pennsylvania.
Morton Cohen, chairman of Clarion
Group, a New York-based hedge fund, described the mass
liquidation of stocks this way: "On a scale of 1 to
10, this sell-off is becoming an 8 or 9."
Watching the stats
|
Only three of the 30 Dow Jones industrials are
up this week, and most are off sharply.
|
A statistical analysis shows how
serious the situation is getting. The Dow has now closed
down seven consecutive sessions, the first time that's
happened since May 1989, says MarketHistory.com. And the
16.2% drop was the worst 7-session streak ever.
The Nasdaq composite and Standard
& Poor's 500 index also have been laid waste this
week. After Thursday's 3.7% drop, the Nasdaq's 4-day
losses swelled to 13.2% — leaving it down 70.9% from its
high. After its 3.1% slide Thursday, the Standard &
Poor's 500 closed at 985, the first time it has closed
below the psychologically important 1000 level since Oct.
13, 1998. All three major indexes are trading at 3-year
lows.
There's no shortage of reasons
investors — both big and small — want out of stocks:
• Investment time frames have
changed. Financial planners say investors with time
horizons of less than 3 to 5 years should be in cash, not
stocks. The swelling number of layoffs — U.S. airlines
have announced job cuts of 100,000 employees in the last
week alone — is having an effect on people hit by the
layoffs: Many need to tap portfolios now to raise cash.
"You can't underestimate the
impact of thousands of people losing their jobs,"
says Fane Lozman, chairman of Scanshift.com. "A lot
of these people can't afford to play the market
anymore."
• Earnings are falling.
Professional investors are revaluing stocks in the wake of
the economic slowdown, which was exacerbated by the
business shutdown caused by the terrorism fears. J.P.
Morgan, for example, is recalculating how much it is
willing to pay for certain stocks, now that long-term
annual earnings growth rates are expected to be closer to
8% to 10%, far below the high-teens growth of the 1990s.
"This is a very strange time," Wolfe says.
"The threat of war throws everyone's earnings
forecasts out the window."
• Some investors who want to
buy stocks can't. To better cope with the damaged
bond-trading systems caused by the attack, The Bond Market
Association recommended this week that government bonds be
settled in 5 days, rather than the usual 1. The new rule
has handcuffed some investors who sold bonds but could not
get their hands on the proceeds of the sale for 5 days,
delaying stock purchases.
"Many who want to buy are
presented with this dilemma," says Tom Stevens,
senior managing director of Wilshire Associates. It's
unclear how widespread the problem is. Creston King,
portfolio manager at David Selected Advisers, says some
bond brokers were able to settle transactions for him in 1
day, as usual. He expects settlements to be back to normal
by Monday.
• Many on Wall Street are in
mourning. Wall Street has endured fear: fear of
recessions, job losses and even depression. But never
before have its key players suffered such an intense
feeling of "tragic sadness," says Steve Leuthold,
head of the Minneapolis-based money management firm Leut
hold Group. "This isn't money, it's friends. In my 40
years in the business, I've never seen such a prevailing
gloom of sadness over the entire community."
The sadness has been compounded by
the depressing sight of red arrows and plunging stock
prices. Unlike a bull market, when any fresh cash lying
around is put to work in stocks immediately, investors are
reluctant to pour the cash they raise from their sales
back into the market.
The ICI reports inflows of $75.4
billion into money market mutual funds this week, the
second-highest ever. The record inflow was $89.3 billion
in January 1998. Almost $67 billion of this week's inflow,
however, came from institutions looking to stash cash in
money funds for the slightly higher yields.
Looking at institutions
Rumors that individuals are the
cause of the market meltdown are simply not true, says Don
Cassidy, senior research analyst for Lipper Analytical. He
believes fund managers, not investors, are doing most of
the selling. Many may be trying to do some "window
dressing" by dumping their losing stocks and beefing
up their cash positions before Sept. 30, the end of the
third quarter, he says.
Despite the steep slide this week,
some say the selling pressure may not have been exhausted.
Todd Salamone, research chief at Schaeffer's Investment
Research, says we haven't reached "the peak of
fear" needed to put in a market bottom.
He notes that the Chicago Board of
Exchange's volatility index — which measures how much
options players are willing to pay for "portfolio
insurance" — now registers 47. When stocks melted
down in October 1998 during the Russian financial crisis,
it reached a high of 60.
But there are a growing number of
money managers who say the recent carnage has taken into
account much of the negative economic fallout sparked by
terrorism. Stocks are getting down to prices that could
spur buying, says Pat Adams of Choice funds.
Even if the market has hit bottom,
many Wall Street pros advise caution until the future
becomes more clear. "We are in a new market
environment," says Gary Anderson, editor of Equity
Portfolio Manager. "The rules have changed."
Contributing: Matt Krantz, John
Waggoner, Sandy Block
|